Are Punitive Damages Available in Personal Injury Cases in California?

The primary goal of a personal injury lawsuit is to compensate you for harm caused by another’s misconduct. However, in some circumstances, the court may also allow punitive damages in addition to compensatory damages. These damages, secured with the legal support of a personal injury attorney in Victorville, CA, are not meant to reimburse you for losses. Instead, they serve a different function: to punish a defendant whose behavior goes far beyond ordinary negligence. 

Under California law, you may recover punitive damages by effectively proving by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant acted with bad intentions or without considering the dangerous ramifications of their actions. These terms have specific legal definitions. 

“Malice” includes conduct that shows a willful disregard for the safety or rights of others. “Oppression” refers to the abuse of power that subjects victims to unjust hardship. “Fraud” involves intentional deception designed to cause harm. All three infringe on a person’s rights under federal and state law. 

Demonstrating Intentional or Reckless Conduct

To support a claim for punitive damages, your evidence must show more than poor judgment or a mistake. For example, if a defendant knowingly drives under the influence of alcohol and causes a crash, that conduct may support a punitive damages claim because it reflects a conscious disregard for safety. Similarly, if a business owner intentionally hides a dangerous condition on their property that causes you harm, that could meet the legal standard for malicious conduct.

Establishing the Defendant’s Financial Condition

California law requires the court to consider the defendant’s financial condition when determining the amount of punitive damages. You must submit evidence that shows the defendant’s wealth, income, or net worth. Courts do this to ensure that the penalty has a meaningful impact based on the defendant’s resources. If you do not present sufficient financial documentation, the court may deny or reduce the punitive award, even if liability is established.

Evaluating Whether Punitive Damages Apply to Your Case

Not all personal injury cases qualify for punitive damages. For example, standard rear-end car accidents caused by distraction or fatigue generally do not rise to the level of malice or oppression. However, if the defendant engaged in road rage, excessive speeding in a residential area, or intentional aggression, you may have a valid claim for additional damages. We examine the facts of your case carefully to determine whether the conduct meets California’s statutory threshold.

Punitive damages in California serve a different legal purpose than compensation. They apply only when the defendant’s behavior is so reckless, malicious, or fraudulent that a financial penalty is justified beyond your actual damages. Schedule a consultation with us today at the Law Offices of Vondra & Hanna in Victorville, CA, and let us help you pursue every legal remedy available to you under California state law.

Posted in Personal Injury | No Comments »